Understanding the Relationship between Insiders and Outsiders at COP

IMG_2494
The automobile worker’s union marching in the downtown Bonn

Walking around the city of white tents and conference rooms at COP, the divide between “insiders” and “outsiders” is stark. This is especially so with COP 23’s separate zones for the negotiations and side events (aka the country delegations and the NGOs). Generally speaking, insiders look to influence the negotiations directly through personal contacts with negotiators. They share their expertise in private meetings, speak alongside ministers in public panels, and even have a hand in drafting the text discussed at the negotiating table. Outsiders, on the other hand, take an indirect approach. They march in the streets of Bonn, organize walk-outs and sit-ins, and display banners in the hallways of COP. In many ways, insiders and outsiders seem to live in different worlds.

While the actions of insiders and outsiders are distinct, it can be difficult to determine whether an actor is an “insider” or an “outsider.” For example, Greenpeace has people on both sides of the fence (literally – security is pretty tight at COP). Activists with Greenpeace take direct action and put on high-profile awareness campaigns – they even sailed a boat up the Rhine to Bonn. But Greenpeace also deploys lawyers who become deeply involved in the nitty-gritty of the negotiations, providing their experience and expertise to country delegates.

IMG_2509
Greenpeace’s ship moored along the shores of the Rhine

Even when the difference between insider and outsider organizations is clear, the distance between these organizations is smaller than it first seems. According to Carroll Muffett, the President and CEO of the Center for International Environmental Law, “civil society organizations are most effective when they don’t stay in their own lanes.” Instead of keeping to their own repertoire of strategies, insiders and outsiders often collaborate to expand their range of action. Insider coalitions like the Climate Action Network may coordinate the positions it takes in the negotiating rooms with the members of the outsider organizations of the Climate Justice Now group. Muffett even recalled instances in which certain country officials would quietly mention that it would help accelerate negotiations if a protest action were to occur.

IMG_2548
One of the most common chants at COP is “Keep It in the Ground.” This banner was unveiled along the walkway between two negotiating areas.

Far from rending civil society apart, the different approaches of insiders and outsiders create strength through diversity. This strength will be tested by the United States’ decision to pull out of the Paris Agreement. In this context, understanding the interdependence of insiders and outsiders, and the wider range of options it affords, is crucial for pushing both the United States and the countries that plan to remain in the UNFCCC toward ambitious and ambitious climate action.

IMG_2569
The President of France, Emmanuel Macron, proposes that “France replace America” when it comes to climate finance.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s